Vaping in Malaysia: Between Scientific Evidence and Religious Decree

No_Vaping_Sign_(18562436519).jpg

Rosli bin Inchep started smoking since the age of 12. For the past 30 years, he can go up to 2 packets a day to satisfy his tobacco fix. But ever since he switched to electronic cigarette, his cravings has reduced tremendously. His first two weeks vaping saw him not going to the nearest store for a packet of cigarettes, an achievement that he could not have imagined. Since then, his breath and body odor is no longer stinks, his appetite improved and insomnia has ceased.

Rosli’s story is just one of many smokers who have resorted to vaping to kick the habit in order to ensure their health and the size of their wallets. Since the product was first introduced in Malaysia back in 2009, e-cigarettes has become the new trend among smokers after flavored roll up tobacco. What was once a privileged item among the rich can now be found among common folks at mamak (street food) stalls.

These past few years saw rise a boon in e-cigarette sales with local, young entrepreneurs making a business in selling e-cigarette and flavoured liquids exported from countries such as Japan and Taiwan. The recent report by Public Health England which stated that e-cigarettes are 95% safer than tobacco cigarettes also contributed to the growth of the local vaping industry which is now the second largest in the world after the United States with a net worth of more than half a billion ringgit.

16087807749_e622ec0827_o.jpg

However this new fad has attracted controversy with various state governments considering an outright ban on sales of e-cigarette bands and the country’s top religious clerics issuing a fatwa (religious edict) that vaping is haram (forbidden) in Islam. National Fatwa Council chairman Tan Sri Dr Abdul Shukor Husin said the decision was made after considering all aspects including syariah law, scientific and medical evidence. “Health experts also found that vape and electronic cigarette could not help smokers and heavy smokers to quit smoking”, he said referring to the studies by the World Health Organization. He further iterated that decision is in line with various Muslim countries such as Bahrain, Qatar and United Arab Emirates which has taken a tough stance on vaping.

Other than health aspect, religious bodies also argued that e-cigarettes lead to unnecessary spending of money and can be distracting from conducting everyday activities. There is also concern that e-cigarette may be similar to tobacco cigarettes which act as a gateway drug, causing smokers to experience an addiction which will escalate to heavy drugs such as morphine and cocaine.

This ruling has received criticism from various quarters of the public from vaping enthusiasts to constitutional lawyers. Small and Middle Entrepreneurs Association which represent the vaping industry questioned the double standard by the authorities on the prohibition of e-cigarettes but no enforcement on tobacco cigarettes.”Why are they not banning cigarettes?Is it because you see Malay leaders and MPs smoking in Parliament so you don’t want to ban cigarettes? Please be fair with your decisions and not act unprofessionally”,said the association president Mohd Ridzuan Abdullah referring to the reports of elected representatives taking a puff between parliamentary sittings.

Lawyers have argued that the states have no authority to enforce a ban on e-cigarettes and that the decision by the National Fatwa Council not binding unless it is gazetted by the state governments. “For them to enforce such a ban, the state fatwa committee must have a fatwa gazetted and it would come under the state’s Shariah criminal offence enactments”, said lawyer Syahredzan Johan. He further stated that issues related to health is under federal jurisdiction in line with the Federal Constitution.

While the vaping industry is facing numerous hurdles, entrepreneurs such as Aimran Abdul Rajak believes that they will wade through the storm. “We need some kind of regulation because vaping can really contribute to the health sector and economy”, said the Vape Empire businessman. While he acknowledge that the long term effects of vaping is unknown, the effects of smoking tobacco cigarettes is scientifically proven.”So isn’t vaping a better alternative?”, he further added.

17679064871_e16aac733d_b

Author: Zakwan Zainal Abidin

Biomedical science researcher turned science journalist, communicator Strives to turn scientific achievements into public understanding

2 thoughts on “Vaping in Malaysia: Between Scientific Evidence and Religious Decree”

  1. Dear webmaster,

    We noticed you used one of our images from our Flickr page:
    E-Cigarette/Electronic Cigarette/E-Cigs/E-Liquid/Vaping

    Our image is used in the following article/post:

    https://scientificnexus.blog/2016/01/11/vaping-in-malaysia-between-scientific-evidence-and-religious-decree/

    We notice you do not use any attributions for using our image. Could you please attribute the image in accordance to the instructions outlined on our Flickr page?

    From our Flickr page on attribution: “If you use this image please credit to, http://vaping360.com/ using a do-follow hyperlink”. If you cannot hyperlink in the picture credit, please leave a do-follow hyperlinked credit at the bottom of the article/post instead.

    Thank you for using our picture and feel free to use any of our other vaping images in the future using the correct attribution.

    Thank you very much.

    Best regards,

    Team Vaping360

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s